SHARPEN YOUR INSTINCTS
5 Questions To Know Which Ones To Trust
3-Minute Read
The instinct that's moved you fastest isn't always the one moving you forward.
What is the simplest way to make dirty water clear?
Leave it alone.
With a little time, everything that is not water separates and falls to the bottom. No filter. No equipment. Just stillness.
Cultivating genuine discernment works the same way.
The founders who can trust their read of a room, a person, a moment, a market move differently. Faster. Less second-guessing. More aligned with what actually works.
Not all gut feelings are the same.
Some are signal. Some are noise. And when your nervous system is running hot, they feel identical.
The founders making the most consequential decisions of their lives often believe they are trusting their instincts. But which ones?
Some instincts lead you to grow. Others are outdated programming keeping you exactly where you are.
Today's issue is about knowing the difference.
your gut always speaks. the question is from where
Your Brain Has Two Modes. Only One Produces Real Discernment.
Your brain's two modes: survival and expression. You can think of them in terms of contraction and expansion.
When the survival brain is activated, whether by pressure, uncertainty, high stakes, unresolved conflict, or threat, it takes over. Its job is protection. It draws from your history, your fears, your most practiced responses. It's fast and confident.
It often sounds exactly like gut wisdom. It is learned fear in disguise. This is contraction, the part of you encoded to hold the line.
When the survival brain is quiet, something else becomes available: expression. Genuine pattern recognition. Long-range thinking. Discernment not shaped by what you are afraid of. Your imagination, creativity, and sense of what's possible wake up.
This is where liberated instinct lives. It's expansion, the part of you encoded to grow.
Both feel certain. What differs is the inner conditions that produce them. One instinct is learned, the other liberated.
Not yet part of The Plenteous Life community? Subscribe to The Grip! Every week you’ll receive additional video, audio, and pdf tools directly in your email inbox to help you create like never before.
What Howard Schultz's Starbucks Turnaround Reveals About Founder Instincts
Former Starbucks CEO, Howard Schultz, was a child when his father was significantly injured at work, lost his job, and came home with nothing: no workers' comp, no health insurance, no plan. The family had no floor beneath them.
That experience wired something into Schultz that he carried for decades: a cellular fear of losing what you have built. In leadership terms, it became a set of instincts that looked like business acumen. Protect the brand obsessively. Control the experience completely. Hold tight to what is working. Don't let go.
For years, these felt like gut wisdom. They were producing results. And they were also fear responses dressed in the language of strategy.
After eight years away, Schultz returned to Starbucks as CEO when it was struggling in 2008. The decisions he made next looked nothing like the instincts that had driven him before. He closed every US store for a single afternoon to retrain baristas. He cut profitable products that had diluted the brand. He made moves that analysts called irrational.
But something had shifted. He described this period as one of deep personal honesty: returning to what the company actually needed rather than what fear was telling him to protect.
The distinction he was making, whether he would have named it this way or not: the scarcity-driven reactivity of his childhood versus genuine signal.
Starbucks came back. The brand came back.
“It often sounds exactly like gut wisdom. It is learned fear in disguise. ”
5 Questions to Separate Signal From Noise Before Your Next Big Decision
Schultz demonstrates what's possible when you make this distinction. The questions below are how. Run them before your next consequential call.
Am I calm right now, or is there urgency underneath this feeling?
Genuine signal does not panic. It is steady. Urgency that feels like instinct is often fear driving the wheel.Does this feeling point toward protection or creation?
The survival brain protects: territory, identity, reputation, past investment.
Liberated instinct creates: possibility, alignment, movement, something new.If I wait 24 hours without acting on this, does it clarify or dissolve?
Not 72 hours. Real signal deepens with time, up to a point. Noise depends on the pressure of the moment to hold its shape. But wait too long and the survival brain rebuilds its case.Is there a fear or pattern from my history that could be generating this response? If yes, when's the earliest I remember feeling this way? What did I make it mean?
Learned instinct speaks from history and is limited by it. Liberated instinct can be informed by history without being constrained by it. Which voice is truly speaking here?When I am genuinely still and the pressure is off, does this signal remain?
Stillness is the test. Whatever survives the quiet is real.
Discernment is built. Question by question. The five above are where you start. If you're ready to go further, a coach or mentor with genuine clarity of their own can show you what you cannot see from where you are.
Run today's questions before your next decision that matters. You will know which instinct to trust.
Keep creating.
key takeaways
Your nervous system generates certainty under pressure regardless of whether the instinct is real signal or learned fear; the source matters more than the strength of the feeling.
Genuine discernment develops when you learn to distinguish which internal state is driving your gut response, not just whether the feeling is confident.
Five specific questions run before a high-stakes call can reveal whether you're operating from genuine wisdom or outdated programming.
WORK 1:1 WITH BECKY
As a self-mastery coach, I help mission-driven founders accelerate desired results without sacrificing what matters. If that sounds like good news, REACH OUT to experience how 1:1 coaching can empower you to be the masterful leader your mission requires.
May you prosper in every way!
Becky & TPL Team
52 Maxims of Conscious Choosing To Create the Deeply Satisfying Life You Desire.